M.
Margaret Knudson, MD, FACS
Professor of Surgery
University of California, San Francisco
Director, San Francisco Injury Center for Research and Prevention
The field of trauma
as a specialty is still relatively young. While care of the injured
patient is historically considered the beginning of the entire field
of surgery, until recently, trauma surgery has always been just a
subset of general surgery. However, with the organization of trauma
care both nationally and internationally, trauma surgery has emerged
as its own specialty. Successful trauma care requires both dedicated
trauma surgeons available on a 24/7 basis, as well as a sufficient
volume of trauma patients to maintain competency. With the advent of
better imaging techniques (ie: helical CT scans, digital ultrasound)
and the application of interventional techniques to the injured
patient (i.e. angiographic embolization, endoscopic stenting), the
field of trauma has expanded to include both operative and
non-operative management of the trauma patient. Due to improvements
in prehospital care and the immediate availability of the trauma team
for initial resuscitation and management of injuries, most trauma
patients that reach the hospital will survive, but many will require
prolonged stays in the intensive care unit. Thus, all trauma surgeons
must now be comfortable managing critically ill patients.
Research in the
field of trauma has focused primarily on the response of the body to
injury, attempting to manage the inflammatory response system which,
when over-activated can lead to multi-organ failure and death. On the
other hand, the compensatory anti-inflamatory regulating system must
be controlled or death will occur from overwhelming sepsis. Trauma
surgeons are active researchers in basic laboratories describing the
response of the body to injury at the cellular level. Outcomes
research is also being eagerly pursued by trauma professionals as
they attempt to develop management guidelines based on high-quality,
clinical studies. On the other end of the spectrum, more and more
trauma surgeons are dedicating their time to the field of injury
control and prevention.
Training Requirements
Residency
Completion of a
general surgery residency is the minimal requirement for working as a
trauma surgeon. However, both academic and non-academic trauma
surgeons are now opting for at least one year of post-graduate
training, primarily in critical care. When choosing a general surgery
residency, a student interested in trauma should select a program
that includes a broad exposure to organized trauma care, including
emergency department training, trauma surgical training, rotations in
orthopedic, neurosurgery, and urologic surgery, and surgical critical
care.
Fellowship Training
Because trauma
surgeons must be competent in surgical critical care, a year of
critical care fellowship is essential. Critical care boards cannot be
obtained without at least one year of critical care training, and
there are restrictions on the number of hours spent during that year
that can be used for trauma surgical call (3 months on the trauma
service). At the end of a one-year critical care fellowship, and
provided that the candidate has already passed general surgical
boards, the fellow can sit for the Special Competency exam for
Surgical Critical Care.
Trauma Fellowship
Many programs
offer a two-year fellowship, one to fulfill the critical care
training, and the second for added experience in trauma surgery.
(Note: There is currently no separate board for trauma surgery
itself). Trauma fellowships are designed to allow the trainee to
learn about the various components of running an organized trauma
service (i.e.: trauma registry, trauma performance improvement) and
to spend time as a junior attending under the guidance of an
experienced trauma surgeon. A complete list of RRC Approved Critical
Care fellowships can be obtained at the website of the American
Association for the Surgery of Trauma (AAST).1 Trauma
fellowship and trauma research opportunities are also listed on that
website.
Board Certification
As mentioned
above, there are no specific boards for trauma surgery itself. After
completion of general surgical boards, a critical care fellowship is
recommended so that specialty boards in surgical critical care can be
obtained.
Grant Funding, Research Fellowships,
Travel Fellowships
Medical Students
Unfortunately,
there is little trauma care education for medical students. A few
will get a surgical rotation in a busy trauma hospital with a trauma
surgeon as a preceptor. Fourth year medical students interested in
trauma will often seek out these positions by rotating to another
program. Trauma research positions do exist for premedical students
at various academic institutions, but there is no central repository
containing this information. Even more tragic, medical students are
taught almost nothing about injury prevention and control, although
there is a move to change the curriculum to accommodate this
deficiency. The AAST1 encourages medical students to
attend their annual scientific meeting and selected students will
have their expenses covered.
Residents
Residents who wish
to pursue careers in trauma surgery should seek out research
positions from one of the 10 NIH centers who have trauma training
grants. These grants are designed for residents who plan an academic
trauma career and are usually for 2 years during mid-residency. Both
basic and clinical research are included at most centers. The
NIH-Trauma Training Centers are listed on the AAST website.1
Faculty
Funds for research
at the faculty level in trauma are very limited. The American
Association for the Surgery of Trauma funds 1-2 trauma research
fellows per year, at the junior faculty level. NIH funds for research
in trauma are almost non-existent, but the Center for Disease Control
for Research and Prevention funds 11 Centers of Excellence in Trauma
Care, two of which are directed by surgeons. Additional funds for
injury and violence prevention projects for individuals are also
available from the CDC.2
Membership in Societies
The American College of Surgeons Committee on Trauma3
Members and
Associate members of the American College of Surgeons (FACS) can join
their local Chapter's Committee on Trauma. By working with the
National COT, the Committees on Trauma assist with designation of
trauma centers, organizing trauma systems, education of trauma
professionals (including sponsoring the Advanced Trauma Life Support
Course), advocating for trauma legislation, and injury prevention
activities.
The American Association for the Surgery of Trauma (AAST)1
This is the
largest academic association of trauma surgeons. Their goal is to
promote trauma research and dissemination of research findings to the
trauma surgical community. Membership requires that the surgeon be a
fellow of the ACS and usually has established him/herself in a
community as a trauma surgeon for at least 1-2 years after completion
of residency/fellowship.
The Eastern Association for the Surgery of Trauma4
This is another
large group of both academic and community surgeons that holds annual
meetings with formal paper presentations. Additionally, they have
developed some very active subcommittees that focus on practice
guidelines and trauma literature reviews. Their prevention committee
has also been very active. The membership tends to be younger than
that of the AAST and it is a good place for a junior attending to
present her first national scientific paper.
The Western Trauma Association5
While being
conceived by a bunch of "ski bums" who also like trauma, the WTA is
the only trauma group with wide-spread representation from trauma
sub-specialists (i.e. orthopedic surgeons, ENT, emergency medicine,
neurosurgery, thoracic surgery). The scientific presentations are of
high quality and most papers are found acceptable for publication in
the Journal of Trauma and Critical Care. The subspecialty involvement
is critical in trauma care, and the WTA will only allow 40% of its
125 members to be from any one field of trauma. This is a great
meeting for residents, fellows, and junior faculty to attend, but one
must be invited by a member. The multi-center study group from WTA
has published close to 20 papers and they are heavily cited in the
trauma literature.
References
1.
American Association for the Surgery of
Trauma:
www.aast.org
2.
Center for Disease Control and
Prevention:
www.cdc.gov.ncipc
3.
Committee on Trauma, American College of
Surgeons:
www.facs.org
4.
Eastern Association for the Surgery of
Trauma:
www.east.org
5.
Western Trauma Association:
www.westerntraumaassociation.org